2021 –
Evan Burke (St. Lawrence University)
Ian Cooke (University of Connecticut)
Jake Elston (University of Scranton)
Christian Johnson (Clark University)
Luke Pliego (University of Massachusetts — Boston)
Nikhil Sheth (Clark University)
Nicholas Sturino (Fairfield University)
2020 –
James Foster (Manhattanville College)
Mack Sloan (Ithaca College)
Sam Vincent (Ithaca College)
2019 –
Max Cotier (University of Virginia)
Trey Fesperman (Xavier University)
Bryce Leckey (Manhattan College)
Jose Mencia (Delware State University)
Chaz Powell (Franklin Pierce University)
Chris Roberti (Stonehill College)
2018 –
Harsha Bollu (Tufts University)
Garrett Crowley (Fordham University)
Brian Gaughan (Central Connecticut State University)
Jordan Perez (Endicott College)
Jake Roper (University of Maine)
2017 –
Dan Brady (Bates College)
Jared Turner (Ithaca College)
2016 –
Justin Proteau (Manhattanville College)
Tyler Serricchio (University of North Carolina – Asheville)
Connor Smith (University of Massachusetts – Amherst)
Michael White (Stonehill College)
2015 –
Richie Barrella (Manhattan College)
Baylor Sundahl (Sacred Heart University, as of 2020 plays professionally for the Sussex County Miners )